Rag doll or baby doll: which is best?
Here’s the question I get asked all the time: which is best, a soft rag doll or a realistic baby doll? And here’s my honest answer. Neither! They both have their own unique place in your child’s heart. Both will be played with just as much, and both will be loved to bits (sometimes literally, hello saggy left arm). It really does come down to personal preference.
What I can help with is the order. Because there is a lovely natural path through baby dolls and rag dolls, from that very first cuddle to a whole wardrobe of tiny outfits. And dolls aren’t just for girls. Any child who loves to cuddle, care, feed, rock and boss someone smaller around (ahem) will love a baby of their own, especially if a real little brother or sister is on the way.

A little confession
I’m going to let you into a secret. This is the first year we’ve stocked “proper” dolls at Binky. And the reason why? Well… I’m a little bit scared of them.
My mum was a doll girl. She still had her china doll from childhood, and it still took pride of place at home when I was a child. Those eyes. They followed you round the room, I swear. I just never particularly liked dolls, so when I opened Binky, I actively avoided them.
But here’s the twist. I can also confess that before Binky, I worked on the design of several doll ranges. I once spent three whole days sat in a conference room discussing the articulation of dolls’ arms. (Three days. On elbows.) So, scared or not, I think I know a fair bit about what dolls are, and what a great play route they are, for development and for pure enjoyment.
Doll play is all about caring, sharing, chatting and copying the grown-ups, and researchers at Cardiff University have even found that playing with dolls lights up the parts of the brain linked to empathy and social skills. So I’ve faced my fears, found dolls I genuinely love (no creepy eyes, I promise), and here we are. Right, back on theme!
Step 1: Start with a soft, cuddly rag doll
For a first doll, I’d always start with a soft, cuddly rag doll. They’re light, squishy, easy to carry around by one leg (the toddler-approved method) and they go in the washing machine when they’ve been dragged through the garden. They become a best friend, a bedtime buddy and a tea party guest all in one.

- Moulin Roty Camélia rag doll, Les Rosalies: dangly arms and legs, a sweet front plait and a removable flower-print dress. Suitable from 10 months.
- Moulin Roty Violette rag doll, Les Rosalies: patterned dungarees, sparkly pumps and beans in her bottom, so she sits up nicely for story time.
- Moulin Roty Marjolaine rag doll, Les Rosalies and Iris: more friends from the same freckly, rosy-cheeked French family.
- Lilliputiens Baby Jeanne and Baby Carrier: a soft fabric baby with her own carrier, so little ones can wear their baby, just like Mum or Dad. From 18 months.
- For fairy fans: the Moulin Roty Les Fées fairies, Ondine, Viviane and Isaline.
Dolls don’t have to look like people
Here’s a little secret from my doll-designing days: a doll doesn’t have to be realistic to be loved like a baby. A bunny in a nightie or a mouse in a matchbox bed gets just as much rocking, feeding and tucking in. Some children (and, ahem, some grown-ups) actually prefer it. No spooky eyes, guaranteed.
That’s why I adore Maileg. These Danish bunnies and mice are beautifully made, full of personality and dressed in the tiniest outfits.
- Maileg My First Bunny in Powder or Mint: a soft first bunny friend for the very littlest.
- Maileg Sleeping Bunny Plush, Small: a sleepy bunny made for snuggles and naps.
- Maileg Little Brother Mouse or Little Sister Mouse in a Matchbox: a tiny mouse with its own matchbox bed. A lovely present for a big brother or sister-to-be.
- Maileg My Cradle in Blue Mint or Light Rose: rock-a-bye, little one.
Step 2: Around two, say hello to a realistic baby doll
By around two years old, realistic baby dolls start coming into play. This is when the nappy changing, bottle feeding and “shhh, baby’s sleeping!” really kicks in. It’s also a brilliant way to get ready for a new little brother or sister. Practising gentle hands, helping with baby’s bath and having a baby of their own to look after while you look after yours can really help (the NHS has some lovely tips on introducing your children to a new baby).
My tip: go for a soft body before a fully rigid one. Simply put, when a doll meets a head (and trust me, it happens, usually mid-tantrum or mid-“look, baby’s flying!”), a soft body causes a lot less harm. Save the all-vinyl bath-time babies for a bit later.
That’s exactly why I love the new Djeco Pomea babies. They’re 32 cm, lightweight and made for little arms, with a soft, floppy body that poses like a real baby, plus a soft-touch vinyl face, hands and feet. Their sleepy eyes close when you lay them down (sweet, not spooky, I checked). Suitable from 18 months.

- Djeco Baby Pomea Doll, Camomille: navy bonnet, mustard muslin top and brown eyes.
- Djeco Baby Pomea Doll, Mimosa: pink pixie bonnet and beautiful black eyes.
- Djeco Baby Pomea Doll, Jacinthe: pink floral romper and the most angelic little face.
Step 3: Dress me up! (The more accessories, the better)
Next up come the full dress-me-up dolls, with all the accessories. And believe me, the more the better. Outfits, bonnets, booties, bottles, bibs, a pram, a cot, a suitcase to pack it all in… This is where doll play turns into storytelling, and where little fingers get a proper workout with buttons, poppers and Velcro.

- Djeco Pomea Lily’s Suitcase and Cerise’s Suitcase: a baby doll plus a change of clothes, bonnet, booties, nappy, bottle and bib, all in a ready-to-gift suitcase. Cerise’s clothes are machine washable too.
- Djeco Pomea Doll Backpack Carrier: baby rides on the back, and there’s room inside for all of baby’s bits. Off we go!
- Moulin Roty Little Wardrobe Suitcase, Les Parisiennes: a chic little doll with a suitcase that opens into a wardrobe, with a mirror, a hanging rail and three outfits.
- Moulin Roty Wardrobe Suitcase, Nini and Sylvain: two dapper mice with raincoats, waistcoats and pyjamas. Fashion for everyone.
- Le Toy Van Retro Wooden Doll Pram and Dolls Wooden Cot: for strolls round the living room and “it’s naptime, everyone be QUIET”.
Step 4: Then everything shrinks… or gets bigger!
After that, dolls go one of two ways. They shrink, or they get larger.
Larger, we’re talking the much bigger collectable dolls with their own books and backstories. Smaller, it’s fashion dolls like Barbie (or Sindy! That was my choice. Poor Sindy, she never quite got the dream house). We don’t stock those at Binky, but if that’s where your little one is heading, go for it.
And if they love tiny things, small-world dolls are pure magic. The Maileg mice really come into their own here, with Twin Baby Mice, the Ballet Mice in their Dance Studio and the SuitCasa, a suitcase that opens up into a whole mouse home. Pop the Le Toy Van Dolls House Family into a dolls house and a whole new world opens up.
My one golden rule
I only have one rule for all dolls, from the very first rag doll to the tiniest mouse: make sure they can be undressed and redressed.
Why? Because getting baby dressed is half the fun. It’s fiddly finger practice for buttons and poppers, it builds independence (the child who dresses their doll is one step closer to dressing themselves, fingers crossed), and it means clothes can come off for a wash after the inevitable yoghurt incident. A doll whose clothes are sewn on is a doll who can only ever wear one outfit. And where’s the fun in that?
My top tips for choosing a doll
- There’s no “best”. Rag doll or baby doll, both get loved just as much. Go with your heart (and theirs).
- Start soft. A cuddly rag doll is the perfect first friend.
- Realistic babies from around two. And go soft-bodied first, for the inevitable head bumps.
- Dolls are for every child. Boys and girls both love a baby to look after, especially with a new little brother or sister on the way.
- Not every doll looks like a person. A Maileg bunny or mouse gets loved just like a baby.
- Accessories make the play. A carrier, a pram, a spare outfit. The more the better.
- Clothes on, clothes off. If they can’t be undressed and redressed, I’d walk on by.
Browse all our dolls and dolls, prams and dolls houses.
Doll FAQs
What is the best first doll for a baby? A soft, cuddly rag doll. It’s light, squishy, washable and easy for little hands to carry. Our Moulin Roty Les Rosalies rag dolls are suitable from 10 months.
Rag doll or baby doll: which is better? Neither is better. Both are loved and played with just as much, so it comes down to personal preference. Many children have one of each: a rag doll first, then a realistic baby doll from around two.
What age is a realistic baby doll for? Around two years old is when realistic baby doll play really takes off, although our Djeco Pomea babies are suitable from 18 months.
Should I choose a soft-body or a hard-body baby doll? For younger children, choose a soft body. Toddlers bump heads, and a soft-bodied doll causes much less harm than a fully rigid one.
Are dolls good for boys? Absolutely. Dolls are for every child. Caring for a baby builds empathy, language and nurturing play, and a baby doll is a lovely way to help any child get ready for a new little brother or sister.
What should I look for in a doll? Make sure the doll can be undressed and redressed. It’s great for fine motor skills and independence, and it means clothes can go in the wash.
Do you sell Barbie, Sindy or American Girl dolls? No, we don’t stock these at Binky. We focus on rag dolls, soft-bodied baby dolls, dress-up dolls and small-world dolls like Maileg mice.